Two weeks ago I had the opportunity to be the Mystery Reader at my daughter’s school. I went back and forth about what books to read and finally landed on “What If” by Samantha Berger and “The Magician’s Hat” by Malcolm Mitchell. The beautiful cover of “What If” drew me in as I browsed the library display at work, and I was familiar with “The Magician’s Hat” from an author’s visit a while back at work.
“What If…” is a beautifully illustrated book, and the storyline is powerful as well. It is Mike Curato’s artistry that really brings this story to life. “What If…” models for the reader a relentless commitment to creativity, dreams, and imagination. Through one example and illustration after another, the author and illustrator walk readers through possibilities that remain even when resources and physical capabilities diminish. The ability to imagine and create with one’s mind remains a powerful force that fans the flame of agency in the bleakest of situations.
“The Magician’s Hat” is special for many reasons. I have great appreciation for the author’s personal story and journey as a reader. Malcolm Mitchell is a former football player and advocate for literacy. He’s shared his challenges and obstacles in growing as a reader as well as his commitment to becoming and helping others become stronger readers. I absolutely love that he read picture books as an adult. I read picture books as an adult. There are gems to be found in some of them. I love that Malcolm vulnerably plugged himself into a book club when he was in college. I love that he found his way and is so intentional about taking away the stigma that some may feel when they struggle to like, love, or get through texts. In “The Magician’s Hat,” Malcolm captivates readers while the magician in his story captivates a young boy who is determined not to be wooed by books.
Reading “The Magician’s Hat” led me to explore other works by Malcolm. In this exploration, I fell in love with, “My Favorite Book in the Whole Wide World.” The main character struggles with reading and to find a book that interests him. His class is given an assignment to bring to class their “favorite book in the whole wide world” - a tall task for a jaded young boy who is also embarrassed to read in front of others. Malcolm uses this piece to remind readers (and teachers of reading) how important it is for readers to see themselves in what they read. The way Malcolm drives home this point in this particular text is so creatively powerful.
All three of these books are opportunities for parents, caretakers, and educators to validate children who find reading challenging, to share challenges they’ve experienced, and to facilitate connection and conversation. The books are also reminders for adults to be intentional about helping children find books within which they can see themselves. Finally, these books are opportunities for young readers to explore ideas of perseverance, resilience, and innovative thinking. These books, like many other picture books, are windows of opportunity to open and inspire hearts and minds. We must recognize, cherish, and seize these opportunities for who knows what healing, hope, inspiration, and intrigue may come from them?